Online gifting is an experience-based category in which emotionally persuasive communication can increase expectations about product quality, delivery reliability and service performance. This exploratory qualitative case study examines how corporate identity and digital integrated marketing communication (IMC) communicate the brand promise of BloomThis MY, a Malaysian digital-first gifting small and medium-sized enterprise (SME), and how fulfilment evidence is made visible and integrated within its digital communication environment. Documentary analysis of five selected product pages, corporate and delivery pages, and 50 customer reviews collected between May and August 2026 was conducted using thematic analysis. Findings indicate that BloomThis foregrounds emotional and visual messaging, while product-level evidence such as dimensions, composition, lifespan and size or variant information is generally available directly on the selected product pages. General substitution conditions are located separately in the website’s Terms and Conditions, requiring additional navigation from the product page. Customer-generated reviews provide an additional layer of evidence through which brand promises may be reinforced, qualified or challenged. The findings suggest a potential promise–proof gap, defined as a possible misalignment between expectations generated by brand communication and the visibility, accessibility and contextual integration of supporting fulfilment evidence. The study proposes the promise–proof perspective as a conceptual extension for future empirical testing and highlights the importance of integrating brand promises with fulfilment evidence and customer experience in digital IMC. Implications are offered for evidence-led, transparent and ethically responsible communication in experience-based SMEs.