High-temperature exposure substantially alters the physical and mechanical properties of concrete, and understanding the underlying degradation mechanisms can provide an important basis for post-fire assessment, emergency response, and repair decisions. In this study, concrete specimens were heated to ten target temperatures (200, 300, 350, 400, 450, 500, 550, 600, 700, and 800∘C) and subsequently subjected to either natural cooling or water cooling. After the specimens had cooled and dried, their surface color, mass, relative dynamic modulus of elasticity, electrical resistance, and compressive strength were measured. Surface alkalinity was assessed by observing color changes following the application of phenolphthalein, while the CIE-L*a*b* color system provided a quantitative description of changes in surface appearance. The findings indicate an association between phenolphthalein-induced surface color and the presence of Ca(OH)2; more intense coloration is consistent with a stronger alkaline response, although the color alone does not directly quantify the compound’s concentration. Mass loss increased with heating temperature, principally reflecting moisture loss and subsequent thermally induced decomposition of hydration products. The development of cracking and changes in moisture state also influenced electrical resistance. With increasing temperature, resistance rose after natural cooling but declined after water cooling, indicating that the cooling procedure influenced the electrical response. Both relative dynamic modulus of elasticity and residual compressive strength decreased as exposure temperature increased, with particularly severe deterioration in the 600–800∘C range. Taken together, the measured variables provide complementary indicators of post-heating damage and show why the cooling history must be considered when assessing the condition of fire-exposed concrete.